Knife Sharpening Mistakes to Avoid: A Guide to Proper Sharpening

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means I may earn a commission if you click on an affiliate link and make a purchase, at no extra cost to you.

Work Sharp Precision Adjust Elite Knife Sharpener - Adjustable Knife Sharpening System - For Hunting, Serrated & Kitchen Knives

Knife Sharpening Stone - Dual Grit Whetstone 400/1000 3000/8000, Knife Sharpening Stone Set, Tpstone Knife Sharpener Tool,Easy to Use

Work Sharp Professional Precision Adjust Knife Sharpener Tool, complete angle adjustable knife sharpening system

🔪 Using a Rock You Found in the Yard

Nature’s whetstone: a jagged rock from your backyard. Yes, you could technically scrape your knife against it. But this is less about sharpening and more about gouging your knife’s edge to oblivion. Rocks from the ground lack controlled grit levels and are far too rough, leading to scratches, chips, and edges so dull you’d have better luck slicing with a spoon.

Do This Instead:
Invest in a high-quality whetstone. Start with a coarser grit (around 1000) to shape the edge, then move up to a finer grit (like 6000 or higher) to refine it. Follow up with a leather strop to polish and remove any burrs left on the blade. This method provides controlled sharpening and maintains the blade’s structure, giving you a razor-sharp edge without the charm of backyard gravel marks.

📏 Testing the Blade on Random Household Items

You've sharpened the knife, and now you’re ready to see just how deadly sharp it is. But please, resist the urge to test it on whatever you see first: thumbtacks, spaghetti noodles, the straps on your backpack, your favorite coffee mug handle—whatever comes to hand. Each "test" dulls the edge you worked so hard to hone. Plus, you’ll end up with a collection of destroyed household items and a knife that’s far from kitchen-ready.

Do This Instead:
Try slicing through a thin piece of paper or a fresh tomato. Both are great indicators of sharpness; the knife should glide cleanly through without snagging or tearing. Even better, use a piece of phone book paper if you want to really test that edge—its thinness reveals the true sharpness without damaging the blade or the paper. By keeping your tests intentional and delicate, you’ll actually gauge your sharpening progress instead of sabotaging it.

🍲 Honing on Kitchen Tiles

“Ceramics can hone a knife, right?” Well, yes, in theory—but not just any ceramic surface will do. Grinding your blade across the kitchen backsplash or that random ceramic dish is more likely to damage both the knife and your decor than actually sharpen the blade. Not to mention, kitchen tiles aren’t designed to create the smooth, even edge you need on a knife—they’ll leave you with nicks and grooves instead.

Do This Instead:
Pick up a ceramic honing rod. These rods are designed specifically to realign the edge of a blade without taking off too much material, restoring sharpness between proper sharpening sessions. Use light, even strokes along the rod at a 15-20 degree angle for most kitchen knives. This keeps your edge intact and your kitchen tiles happily free of knife marks.

🔪 Bonus Blunder: Using Your Jeans as a Strop

For those who really want to live on the edge—pun intended—there’s the classic jeans strop. You’ll hear people rave about finishing a sharpened edge by rubbing the knife along their denim. While it might work in a pinch, this is not a reliable substitute for an actual leather strop. You risk scratching the knife, dulling the blade, and ruining a perfectly good pair of jeans.

Do This Instead:
Opt for a leather strop, which provides a controlled surface to polish the edge and remove any microscopic burrs left from sharpening. Apply a bit of honing compound to the leather for an even sharper edge. Strop away from the edge (not into it) to avoid cutting into the leather. This step puts the final touch on your sharpening process, leaving the knife razor-sharp and ready for action.

🎉 Did You Know? 🔍

🧄 Cutting Certain Foods Can Dull Your Blade Faster
Surprisingly, chopping up foods like garlic, onions, or even acidic ingredients such as tomatoes can speed up the dulling process. The acid in these foods can actually wear down the edge of your blade, especially if left on the knife without cleaning. A quick rinse and dry after slicing acidic or sticky ingredients can help preserve sharpness.

🍋 Leaving Knives Wet Causes More Than Just Rust
While rust is an obvious risk, leaving your knife wet also promotes micro-corrosion along the edge, which dulls it over time. Even stainless steel knives aren’t immune. Always dry your blade thoroughly after use—it's not just about keeping it rust-free; it also keeps the edge keen.

🔍 Your Cutting Board Matters
Glass or ceramic cutting boards may look fancy, but they’re notorious for dulling blades quickly. Every cut on a hard surface causes micro-damage to the edge, while a wood or plastic board provides a bit of “give” that preserves sharpness longer. Bamboo is also a great choice, as it’s dense but softer on edges than glass or ceramic.

💼 Storage Can Dull Your Knives
Throwing your knives into a drawer without protection can be as damaging as chopping on a rock. Knives jostling against other utensils dulls the edge quickly. The best storage? A knife block, magnetic strip, or a blade cover for safe drawer storage.

🔥 Heat Weakens Your Edge
If you've ever been tempted to put your knife in the dishwasher—resist. The high heat and detergent chemicals not only dull the blade but can also warp and weaken the steel over time. Stick to gentle handwashing to protect that edge.

💡 Stropping Adds Extra Sharpness
Most people know to hone a knife, but few think to strop, which polishes the blade to a razor-sharp finish. Stropping removes any microscopic burrs left from sharpening, giving you an edge so sharp you could slice paper with a whisper. Leather strops are the traditional go-to, but you can also use denim (carefully!) in a pinch if you’re cautious and steady.

🎉 Ending Thoughts
There’s a fine line between creativity and chaos in knife sharpening. Avoiding shortcuts and DIY disasters will save your knife’s edge and keep your household items intact. With the right tools and methods, you’ll not only sharpen like a pro, but you’ll also keep your knives gleaming and ready for action without unnecessary trips to the yard—or your jeans drawer.

Ready to Master the Art of Sharpening?

Sharpen your skills (and your blade) with our full guide on How to Sharpen a Knife! Visit How to Sharpen a Knife: A Comprehensive Guide for pro tips, techniques, and expert advice straight from Chief Warhammer Blades. Get the edge you deserve!

Enjoyed the Tips? Share the Wisdom!

Help others avoid sharpening disasters by sharing this guide with fellow knife enthusiasts! 🗡️ Spread the word and keep those edges sharp!